Proof:

The hypothesis implies that the pair $ {\cal U} = \{$int$ \;A,\; X - \overline{U}\}$ is an open cover of $ X$, where $ \overline{U}$ denotes the closure of $ U$. Likewise $ {\cal V} = \{$int$ \;A,\; A - \overline{U}\}$ is an open cover of $ A$ and $ S^{\;{\cal V}}(A)$ is a subcomplex of $ S^{\;{\cal U}}(X)$. By theorem (29.6) the short exact sequence of complexes

$\displaystyle \begin{CD}
0@> >> S^{\;{\cal V}}(A) @> >> S^{\;{\cal U}}(X) @> >> S^{\;{\cal U}}(X)/S^{\;{\cal V}}(A) @> >> 0
\end{CD}$

gives rise to a long exact sequence in homology:

$\displaystyle \begin{CD}
@> >> H^{\;{\cal V}}_n(A) @> >> H^{\;{\cal U}}_n(X) @>...
...{\cal U}}(X)/S^{\;{\cal V}}(A)) @> >>
H^{\;{\cal V}}_{n-1}(A)@> >>
\end{CD}
$

On the other hand there is an obvious map of complexes induced by the inclusion maps namely

$\displaystyle \begin{CD}
j\;:\;S^{\;{\cal U}}(X)/S^{\;{\cal V}}(A) @> >> S(X)/S(A),
\end{CD}
$

resulting in a commutative diagram of chain complexes

$\displaystyle \begin{CD}
0@> >> S^{\;{\cal V}}(A) @> >> S^{\;{\cal U}}(X) @> >>...
...} V @VV j V @.\\
0@> >> S(A) @> >> S(X) @> >> S(X)/S(A) @> >> 0 \\
\end{CD}
$

Since the long exact sequence in homology is natural (exercise 6 of lecture 29), we get the commutative diagram:
$ \begin{CD}
@> >> H^{\;{\cal V}}_n(A) @> {i} >> H^{\;{\cal U}}_n(X) @> p >> H_n...
...(X) @> {p}>> H_n(S(X)/S(A)) @> >> H_{n-1}(A) @> >> H_{n-1}(X) @> >>\\
\end{CD}$
where we the subscript star indicates the map induced in homology. The five lemma enables us to conclude that

$\displaystyle j_*\;:\; H_n(S^{\;{\cal U}}(X)/S^{\;{\cal V}}(A)) \longrightarrow H_n(S(X)/S(A)) = H_n(X, A).
$

is an isomorphism. Note the inclusion

$\displaystyle k\;:\; S(X-U)\longrightarrow S^{\;{\cal U}}(X)
$

maps $ S(A-U)$ into $ S^{\;{\cal V}}(A)$ whereby we get an isomorphism (exercise 2)

$\displaystyle \overline{k}\;:\;S(X-U)/S(A-U) = S^{\;{\cal U}}(X)/S^{\;{\cal V}}(A). \eqno(38.2)
$

The composite $ j\circ \overline{k}$ is also induced by the inclusion map $ (X-U,\; A-U)\longrightarrow (X, A)$ and we have the desired isomorphism

$\displaystyle (j\circ\overline{k})_*\;:\; H_n(X-U, A-U)\longrightarrow H_n(X, A),\quad n = 0, 1, 2, \dots
$

nisha 2012-03-20