Module 3 : Social Structure and Social Change

Lecture 1 : Social Structure and Social Change: Basic Concepts

 

Cultural lag is a commonly observed phenomenon, where the development of culture falls out of step with developments in technology, politics or economics.

The problems presented by the empirical study of social change are formidable. Historical data are invariably incomplete or biased, and long-term studies of ongoing change are expensive and difficult.

The 19th-century equation of change with progress is no longer widely accepted. Change may be regressive, or destructive, or confused by cultural lag. It remains an open question to what extent sociologists can explain or predict social change, and therefore to what extent societies can ever reliably initiate or control change in directions deemed socially desirable, or in any direction at all.

The modern age takes a much less holistic view of change. Change is seen as natural and necessary – something that is positive rather than negative. Each generation faces new and different challenges to those of the previous one, so that it seems implausible to imagine that continuity with the past is all-important. With the European Enlightenment in the 18th century, liberals begin to postulate a doctrine of progress – change is celebrated and admired. This doctrine of progress is contradicted by perfectionism, which ascribes animating change to a timeless creator, so that inevitably at some point in the future the perfect society will arrive. Some conservatives reject the notion of progress itself as though the idea is an inherently perfectionist one. It is important to subject the argument about progress to an internal critique: it is not that the notion of progress is problematic, but rather the idea that this progress has a beginning and an end – concepts which undermine the dynamism of change.

The conservative condemns change as a bad thing, the radical sees it as good, but each position betrays a numbing one-sidedness. Change to be meaningful must be expressed through continuity with the past so that newness can be critically appraised. Change must be tied to absolute as well as relative standpoints – do new ideas and practices help us govern our own lives in a more satisfactory fashion? The concepts of self-government and autonomy express a longstanding aspiration – inherent in all systems of morality – and they enable us to decide whether change is positive and developmental, or negative and self-destructive.

It is also important to tackle the question of the source of change. Why do societies change? It is perfectly true that people develop new ideas and attitudes – but why? The idealists treat ideas as autonomous agents with an origin in mystical genius – either of the outstanding individual or of a supernatural creator. Materialists rightly insist that change derives from forces outside the consciousness of people – that is, change occurs whether people like it or not.

The materialist argument is a powerful one, for it seeks to locate change in circumstances that operate structurally, that is, in collective “forces” that people can never wholly control. For example, the demand by women for socioeconomic as well as political equality arises not simply greater equality is a “good idea”. More and more women work outside the home and undertake occupations of a nontraditional kind. This breaks down patriarchal stereotypes, although it also provokes fundamentalist backlashes. The point is that, although the change is expressed in debate and argument, these new ideas (and new language) cannot simply be understood on their own terms. They seem plausible because they correspond to changing realities in society itself.