Module 3 : Social Structure and Social Change

Lecture 1 : Social Structure and Social Change: Basic Concepts

 

Theoretical Perspectives on Social Change

Sociologists have explored the question of change largely by the close analysis of particular change processes, and by refining definitions. Social change theories how encompass a very broad range of phenomena, including short-term and long-term, large-scale and small-scale changes, from the level of global society to the level of the family. Dramatic structural and economic changes such as occurred in Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union at the beginning of the 1990s are only one part of the field. Sociologists are also interested in changes that affect norms, values, behaviour, cultural meanings and social relationships.

One legacy of Saint-Simon and Auguste Comte, as refracted through the work of Emile Durkheim, is the theory of functionalism associated with the names of Talcott Parsons and Wilbert E. Moore. If society is viewed as a complex and interconnected pattern of functions, change can be explained as an epiphenomenon of the constant search for equilibrium (Marshall 2010). For example, mass unemployment may generate a welfare system, or radical conflict may generate legislative action. The ramifications of any particular social change are endless and unpredictable, but all can be understood as social adjustments to some failure or ‘dysfunction’ within the social organism.

A systematic functional attempt to specify the structural determinants of change can be found in the work of American sociologist Neil J. Smelser. In an empirical study of Social Change in the Industrial Revolution (1959), Smelser analyzed the interrelationship between the growth and organization of the cotton industry and the structure of the family, during the industrialization process in 19th-century England. In this early work, a model is proposed to explain the differentiation of social systems, based on an analysis of the way in which these two particular systems – cotton industry and the family – responded to forces for change. In his subsequent writings, for example Theory of Collective Behaviour (1963), Smelser both refined this model and applied it to a variety of types of collective action. He conceptualizes social change as a ‘value-added’ process, in which a number of conditions or stages are sequentially combined, before eventually producing a particular social change. This approach minimalizes, but does not wholly ignore, the more proximate causes of social change.

The Marxist and conflict theory traditions have developed along different lines, although they share important underlying assumptions with functionalism. The Marxist theory of change is more proactive, focusing on the ability of human beings to influence their own fates through political action. Conflict theories in general – not necessarily Marxist – explain social change as the outcome of a struggle for advantage between classes, races or other groups, rather than a search for consensus. Daniel Bell’s Cultural Contradictions of Capitalism (1976) provides an interesting turn to the conflict perspective by suggesting that change in the modern world arises out of the tension between three ‘realms’ of social reality which operate on different principles and move towards different goals: (i) the techno-economic structure (science, industry and the economy); (ii) the political system; and (iii) culture. 19th-century theorists saw change as a total, homogeneous process, where every aspect of society would change together. We now know that, as Bell’s model suggests, change is often uneven and partial.