With the onset of modernity – ushering in of the Industrial Revolution, emergence of modern science and critical thinking, such notions dramatically changed. People are presented as individuals who can choose which role they play and change from one role to another. Structures seemingly dissolve into agency, so that what matters is the will of individuals to alter the world in which they find themselves. The problem with this position is that not only is agency presented abstractly – that is, as outside society – but the same abstract force that enables some to be actors condemns others to passivity. Hence the classical liberals limited their notion of the individual to men who owned property, were Protestants (in the West) and upper castes (in India), and had the correct ethnicity. Timeless structures had not disappeared – they were merely assigned to others.
Embodied structures are found in the habits and skills that are inscribed in human bodies and minds and that allow them to produce, reproduce, and transform institutional structures and relational structures – norms, values, interests, procedures and social interaction.
The emphasis upon agency and the individual is important, but it needs to be linked dynamically and historically to the notion of structure. People became conscious actors not simply because they had changed their ideas, but because they acquired through the market the wealth that enabled them to command the services of others. They may have imagined that social structures simply affected others – women, the poor, backward castes, the residents of the colonies, and so forth. But this is an illusion. The market is itself a social structure and, as such, dictates to beneficiaries and victims alike how they are to conduct themselves. Social structures are the product of agency. Without conscious action, there would be no structures. But what makes a practice structural is that the patterning which results has implications and imposes constraints that correspond only imperfectly to the intentions of those who created them.
The structural argument that people enter social relations independent of their will cannot mean that these relations are the product of automatons – creatures without intention and purpose. What it means is that the result of activities undertaken is never the same as the intention of those who undertook these activities; it is this gap between intention and consequence that creates the structural character of activity. It is not that these structures are brought about by the will of some higher power, but human activity in which intention and result hardly coincide.
Being aware of this makes it possible to try and organize our activities with greater consideration of their likely consequences. It is, however, a mistake to imagine that any society, no matter how enlightened and well regulated, can extinguish the gulf between intention and result, since the fallibility of humans and the complexity of social practices make it inevitable that agency and structure will remain distinct.
Social Change
Social change is one of the central research problems of sociology, where change is not seen as a mere succession of separate events but as a structured process in which it may be possible to identify a specific direction or tendency.